Back to Journal

    November 20, 2026

    Where Is the Thinking?

    By Olivia Odileke

    It's three o'clock in the morning, and I can't sleep. One question keeps circling back: Where is the thinking?

    I see its absence everywhere. I have called customer support lines with an unusual problem and I hear, "That's our policy." People accept information without asking where it came from. Simple problems stay unsolved because no one stepped back to ask what is actually causing them.

    Then I think about our schools.

    Rules or principles?

    The difference between following a rule and applying a principle has always fascinated me. In my own faith, Jesus was asked for the greatest commandment and gave two: love God, and love your neighbor as yourself. Everything else, he said, hangs on those.

    Notice what that requires. There is no checklist. In every situation you have to ask: How would I want to be treated? What does love call for here? Principles demand thinking. Whatever your tradition, the design is striking: the highest authority handed people principles and trusted them to reason.

    Do our schools extend that trust to children? We tell students what to read, which questions to answer, how to organize their responses, and when the work is due. Supports help. But when we make every intellectual decision for students, we raise task completers, not thinkers. The thinking is missing because we have not yet required it.

    The trouble with mastery

    In K-12 education we love one word: mastery. We design assessments to measure it, interventions to reach it, and now AI-powered pathways to speed it along. I've started to wrestle with that word. What exactly are students mastering?

    I have observed students who can solve ten problems with a practiced procedure and freeze when the eleventh looks different. Foundational skills matter, and fluency matters. But I worry we've become so good at measuring what is easy to measure that we've stopped asking about the thinking behind it.

    AI sharpens the concern. Adaptive tools can personalize the path, give instant feedback, and keep a dashboard green. That has real value. But personalizing the path does not deepen the thinking along it. A child can earn every badge, and I still want to know: What did she have to figure out on her own? If the answer is “very little,” then mastery has become a record of compliance, not of thought.

    Same standard, two classrooms

    Picture two fourth-grade rooms teaching the same standard: finding the area of rectangles.

    Room A: Students get a worksheet of twenty rectangles with labeled sides. They multiply length by width, fill in the blanks, and check answers with a partner. The lesson is orderly, on standard, and done in thirty minutes. A walkthrough form would give it full marks.

    Room B: The teacher poses one problem: “We have 24 square tiles to cover the floor of the reading nook. Show me every rectangle you can make. What do you notice?” Students build, sketch, and argue. They discover that a 3-by-8 and a 4-by-6 look nothing alike but cover exactly the same amount of floor. Then someone asks, “Does that work with 30 tiles?”

    Same standard. Same multiplication. But in Room B the formula is a tool students reached for, not steps they followed. Both rooms may do equally well on Friday’s quiz. Only in Room B can I point to the thinking: the noticing, the arguing, the question nobody assigned. A score can’t show the difference. A principal asking “Where is the thinking?” can see it in two minutes and can ask the Room A teacher what would need to change for students to do more of the figuring themselves.

    What a thinker looks like

    In his autobiography, Benjamin Franklin describes finding a poor woman sweeping the pavement at his door in London one morning. Most of us would have nodded and gone inside. Franklin noticed how much she accomplished in so little time. That observation became a proposal: contract the watchmen to keep streets swept and give poor people the work.

    He noticed, he wondered, and he acted, with no technology, committee, or mandate. How many Franklins are sitting in our classrooms, learning that their questions are interruptions? What might a ten-year-old propose if we gave him a real audience? Thinking becomes visible when we create space for students to notice, question, and act on what they see, not only complete what we assign.

    Potential is not a performance level

    Below basic, basic, proficient, advanced. These labels serve an assessment purpose, but they can't capture a person. The student who struggles to read at grade level may have extraordinary spatial reasoning. The quiet one may be spotting patterns everyone else misses. The one who questions the directions may have the start of an innovative mind that needs guidance, not suppression.

    Making learning accessible is not the same as making it easier. We can provide scaffolds, models, and vocabulary support and still expect every child to reason, question, and make meaning. When we look only at performance levels, we miss the thinking that is already there, and we fail to design the next step that would stretch it. Stakeholders who want more thinking must look past the label to the reasoning itself.

    Where to look on Monday

    We don't need another initiative. We need better questions.

    For teachers: Is tomorrow's lesson Room A or Room B? What will students have to figure out for themselves?

    For principals: On classroom visits, look for evidence of student thinking, not just compliance. Open your next PLC not with a score report but with, "Where did students reason independently? Where did they get stuck, and what did they do next?"

    For curriculum: Take one chapter and ask where it requires students to reason rather than recall. AI can help surface the answer, but a teacher must judge what builds understanding.

    When we teach to the average, we get average thinking. Our children deserve to be taught to their potential, because they will face problems no textbook answers.

    So tomorrow, in a classroom, a PLC, or a district meeting, ask one question: Where is the thinking?

    Olivia Odileke is the founder of Kampus Insights CC and author of The Question-Driven Principal. A former Title I classroom teacher and instructional coach, she has worked with hundreds of principals to develop deep thinking classrooms.


    This is the work Lead Spark Team was built to support: leadership teams choosing one instructional challenge, one practice, and one teacher team, and looking for student thinking together in a short cycle. School leadership teams can register for a complimentary 45 day Lead Spark Team pilot here: app.leadsparkteam.com/signup

    Lead Spark Team

    See where your improvement process is actually breaking

    In 30 minutes, look at what is working in your school, where walkthroughs and PLCs stop changing practice, and what one focused cycle would look like. No credit card. No prep required.